Skip to main content

Playing on Uneven Ground: Franklin & Marshall Baseball’s Deal with the Lancaster Stormers Creates a Professional-Level Advantage, While Softball Is Left on the Sidelines

file

Photo Source: Michael Stokes, DSC_0010, Flickr (May 10, 2018) (CC BY 2.0)

By: Gia Angiolillo*                                                                       Posted: 10/30/2026

 

Franklin & Marshall College’s new partnership with the Lancaster Stormers raises a question that reaches beyond where a team plays: when a college makes a major investment in one athletic program, how does it ensure that its other athletes receive equal opportunity?[1] Beginning in 2027, the eight-year agreement will make Penn Medicine Park the official home of Diplomats Baseball, with practices and home games at the professional stadium, dedicated locker rooms, equipment storage, and access to professional training environments.[2] The partnership does not establish a Title IX violation, but it creates a concrete opportunity to examine whether F&M’s athletic resources provide equivalent benefits to its male and female athletes.[3]

 

A Whole Different Ballgame

Title IX prohibits sex discrimination in federally funded education programs and requires equal athletic opportunities regardless of sex.[4]  Its implementing regulations require institutions to consider the availability and quality of equipment, coaching, locker rooms, practice and competitive facilities, and medical and training services.[5] Although Title IX does not mandate identical resources, institutions must evaluate these benefits collectively to determine whether any disparities, in the aggregate, deny male and female athletes’ equivalent athletic opportunities.[6]

Third Circuit precedent requires evaluating athletic opportunity in substance, not merely by comparing team counts.[7]  In Williams v. School District of Bethlehem[8], a male high school student challenged his exclusion from the girls’ field hockey team because the school did not offer a boys’ team.[9] The court explained that Title IX compliance turns on whether “disparities of a substantial and unjustified nature exist in the benefits, treatment, services, or opportunities afforded male and female athletes” across the institution’s athletic program.[10] Although Williams concerned sex-based eligibility restrictions rather than unequal facilities, it provides context for assessing whether athletic opportunities are meaningful in practice.[11]

In Favia v. Indiana University of Pennsylvania[12], female athletes challenged the university’s decision to eliminate women’s field hockey and gymnastics programs amid budget cuts.[13] Despite eliminating equal numbers of men’s and women’s teams, the university provided unequal participation opportunities and disproportionately fewer athletic scholarship funds to women.[14] The Third Circuit upheld the injunction requiring reinstatement of the women’s programs, recognizing that the University did not provide male and female athletes with equal athletic opportunity.[15] Additionally, although unequal expenditures alone do not establish a violation, team funding remains relevant because it affects the resources available to athletes.[16] These principles support the necessity of examining whether disparities in facilities and other benefits undermine equal athletic opportunity under Title IX and federal regulations for nondiscrimination on the basis of sex in education programs.[17]

 

Trailing Behind

F&M softball has a designated home field at Baker Campus, completed in 2004 and equipped with fencing and outdoor batting cages.[18]  However, the existence of a softball field does not end the inquiry into whether the baseball and softball teams have access to facilities that provide equal athletic opportunity.[19] Baseball’s Caplan Field has routinely received upgrades to its infield, dugouts, warning track, batting facilities, and press box, while Baker Campus Field’s asymmetrical outfield fence would be considered noncompliant if it were beholden to the same NCAA guidelines that any newly constructed fields are.[20]  Although these differences do not establish a Title IX violation in and of itself, they raise a legitimate question about whether F&M has adequately assessed softball’s facility needs alongside its investments in baseball.[21]

The disparity is all the more striking because F&M has indicated that Caplan Field will remain available for baseball practices, games as needed, camps, and clinics even after the team moves to Penn Medicine Park.[22] Baseball will thus benefit from both an upgraded former home and a professional stadium, while softball remains down a hill and in the corner of Baker Campus.[23] Importantly, Caplan cannot serve as a softball facility when baseball is not using it: baseball and softball require different field configurations, meaning if adaptation was considered it would require careful evaluation and potentially significant permanent modifications to the field.[24] The main concern then is not whether softball should use Caplan, but why baseball stands to benefit from two well-equipped facilities while softball receives no comparable investment in its own facilities.[25] Public information does not reveal what alternatives, if any, the College has considered for the softball team, or how it plans to ensure equivalent benefits to both teams in light of this new partnership.[26]

Additionally, the disparity extends beyond facilities to the developmental opportunities each program receives.[27] Baseball’s partnership offers players access to a professional stadium and training environment, potentially providing exposure to professional operations, coaching, and career pathways.[28] Softball players have professional opportunities, too, as demonstrated by the launch of the Athletes Unlimited Softball League.[29] Title IX does not require F&M to secure an identical partnership for softball, but the College should explain how baseball will benefit from this arrangement, what comparable developmental resources softball receives, and how both programs will have meaningful opportunities to advance their athletic goals.[30]

 

The Score Isn’t Final

F&M has shown its commitment to giving baseball a first-class athletic environment.[31] Now, will the College show that softball deserves the same investment in facilities, resources, and exposure?[32] Ultimately, F&M must demonstrate that baseball’s leap forward does not leave softball behind.[33]

 

[1] See Baseball Makes Historic Partnership with Penn Medicine Park, Franklin & Marshall Coll. (Aug. 11, 2026), https://godiplomats.com/news/2026/8/11/baseball-makes-historic-partnership-with-penn-medicine-park.aspx (announcing College’s partnership with Lancaster Stormers); see also 34 C.F.R. § 106.41(c) (2018) (identifying factors relevant to determining whether institutions provide equal athletic opportunities to members of both sexes).

[2] See Press Release, Franklin & Marshall Coll. & Lancaster Stormers, Franklin & Marshall College and Lancaster Stormers Announce Historic 8-Year Partnership Naming Penn Medicine Park the Home of Diplomats Baseball [hereinafter Home of Diplomats Baseball Press Release] (Aug. 11, 2026), https://www.lancasterstormers.com/franklin-marshall-college-and-lancaster-stormers-announce-historic-8-year-partnership-naming-penn-medicine-park-the-home-of-diplomats-baseball/ (announcing eight-year agreement establishing Penn Medicine Park as F&M baseball’s official home stadium beginning in spring 2027, with all practices and home games held at stadium and access to dedicated locker rooms, equipment storage, and professional training facilities).

[3] See 34 C.F.R. § 106.41(c)(2), (7) (identifying  provisions of equipment and locker rooms, practice and competitive facilities, and other program components as factors relevant to determining whether institution provides equal athletic opportunity); see also Nondiscrimination on the Basis of Sex in Education Programs or Activities Receiving Federal Financial Assistance, 44 Fed. Reg. 71,413, 71,415–17 (Dec. 11, 1979) (explaining that Title IX compliance requires consideration of relative availability, quality, and kind of benefits, opportunities, and treatment afforded male and female athletes, and that substantial and unjustified disparities may establish noncompliance).

[4] See 20 U.S.C. § 1681(a) (prohibiting sex discrimination under any education program or activity receiving federal financial assistance, subject to statutory exceptions); see also 34 C.F.R. § 106.41(c) (requiring institutions sponsoring athletics to provide equal athletic opportunity for members of both sexes).

[5] See 34 C.F.R. § 106.41(c)(2)–(8) (identifying, among other factors, provisions of equipment and supplies, scheduling of games and practice times, travel and per diem allowances, opportunity to receive coaching and academic tutoring, assignment and compensation of coaches, locker rooms and practice and competitive facilities, and medical and training facilities and services as relevant to determining whether equal athletic opportunity is provided); see also Nondiscrimination on the Basis of Sex in Education Programs or Activities Receiving Federal Financial Assistance, 44 Fed. Reg. 71,413, 71,415–17 (Dec. 11, 1979), supra note 3 (explaining that institutions must compare availability, quality, and kind of athletic benefits and opportunities afforded to male and female athletes).

[6] See id. (explaining that equal athletic opportunity does not require identical benefits, opportunities, or treatment, but requires consideration of relative availability, quality, and kind of program components and recognizes that substantial and unjustified disparities may establish noncompliance); see also Portz v. St. Cloud State Univ., 16 F.4th 577, 581–83 (8th Cir. 2021) (discussing Department of Education’s framework for evaluating disparities in athletic treatment and benefits, including whether disparities across athletic program or within individual program component deny equal athletic opportunity).

[7] See Williams v. Sch. Dist. of Bethlehem, 998 F.2d 168, 171–72 (3d Cir. 1993) (explaining that Title IX compliance in athletics cannot be measured simply by comparing number of teams available to each sex, but instead requires consideration of whether substantial and unjustified disparities exist in benefits, treatment, services, or opportunities afforded male and female athletes); see also Favia v. Ind. Univ. of Pa., 7 F.3d 332, 343–44 (3d Cir. 1993) (recognizing that unequal expenditures do not necessarily establish noncompliance but that funding remains relevant to determining whether equal athletic opportunity exists).

[8] 998 F.2d 168 (3d Cir. 1993).

[9] See id. at 170–71 (considering male student’s Title IX challenge to his exclusion from girls’ field hockey team at school that did not offer boys’ field hockey team).

[10] See id. at 176 (quoting Department of Education’s Title IX athletics Policy Interpretation and explaining that measuring compliance requires assessing whether substantial and unjustified disparities exist in benefits, treatment, services, or opportunities afforded male and female athletes across institution’s athletic program).

[11] See id. at 170–76 (addressing male student’s challenge to his exclusion from girls’ field hockey team and discussing Title IX’s application to athletic participation and equal opportunity); see also 34 C.F.R. § 106.41(c)(2)–(8) (2018) (identifying equipment, coaching, locker rooms, practice and competitive facilities, and medical and training services as factors relevant to evaluating equal athletic opportunity).

[12] 7 F.3d 332 (3d Cir. 1993).

[13] See id. at 334–36 (considering female student-athletes’ challenge to Indiana University of Pennsylvania’s decision to eliminate its women’s field hockey and gymnastics programs as part of budget reductions affecting university’s athletic department).

[14] See id. at 334–35 (noting that university fielded nine men’s and nine women’s varsity teams, yet male teams offered 313 participation opportunities compared with 190 for female teams, and that women received only twenty-one percent of athletic scholarship funds in 1991).

[15] See id. at 343–44 (affirming preliminary injunction requiring reinstatement of women’s field hockey and gymnastics teams and explaining that Title IX compliance requires consideration of actual athletic participation opportunities rather than team counts alone).

[16] See id. (explaining that unequal expenditures do not, standing alone, establish Title IX violation, but evaluating financial resources and athletic scholarship allocations as part of broader inquiry into equal athletic opportunity); see also Nondiscrimination on the Basis of Sex in Education Programs or Activities Receiving Federal Financial Assistance, 44 Fed. Reg. 71,413, 71,415–17 (Dec. 11, 1979), supra note 3 (directing institutions to assess the availability, quality, and kind of athletic benefits and opportunities and to consider whether substantial and unjustified disparities deny equal athletic opportunity).

[17] See 34 C.F.R. § 106.41(c)(2), (4)–(8) (2018) (identifying equipment, coaching, locker rooms, practice and competitive facilities, and medical and training services as factors in determining whether equal athletic opportunity is provided); see also Favia, 7 F.3d at 343–44 (examining athletic participation opportunities and financial resources in evaluating a Title IX challenge to the elimination of women’s varsity teams); Williams v. Sch. Dist. of Bethlehem, 998 F.2d 168, 176 (3d Cir. 1993) (discussing  standard for determining whether substantial and unjustified disparities in athletic benefits, treatment, services, or opportunities deny equal athletic opportunity).

[18] See Baker Campus Fields, Franklin & Marshall Coll., https://godiplomats.com/facilities/baker-campus-fields/9 (last visited Oct. 11, 2026) (identifying Baker Campus Field as home facility for F&M softball, stating that facility was completed in 2004, and describing its existing amenities, including fencing and outdoor batting cages).

[19] See 34 C.F.R. § 106.41(c)(7) (2018) (identifying provision of locker rooms, practice facilities, and competitive facilities as factors relevant to determining whether equal athletic opportunity exists); see also Landow v. Sch. Bd. of Brevard Cnty., 132 F. Supp. 2d 958, 962–66 (M.D. Fla. 2000) (comparing baseball and softball facilities and evaluating cumulative effect of differences in field characteristics, equipment, and related amenities rather than treating existence of facility for each team as dispositive).

[20] See Caplan Field, Franklin & Marshall Coll., https://godiplomats.com/sports/2023/5/18/caplan-field.aspx (last visited Oct. 11, 2026) (documenting improvements to baseball facility, including laser-grading and top-dressing infield in 2020, expanding dugouts in 2012, installing new dugout rails and padding in 2018, adding warning track in 2017, and maintaining batting cage and press box); see also Baker Campus Softball Field, Franklin & Marshall Coll., https://godiplomats.com/sports/2023/4/25/Facilities-Baker-softball.aspx (last visited Oct. 11, 2026) (providing photographs of softball facility and its outfield fence); Division III Softball Host Operations Manual, NCAA 34–35 (2025–26), https://ncaaorg.s3.amazonaws.com/championships/sports/softball/d3/2025-26D3WSB_HostOpsManual.pdf (requiring newly constructed fields to have fence at least six feet high and minimum distances of 200 feet down left- and right-field lines and 220 feet to center field, while setting different recommendations or requirements for certain existing fields).

[21] See 34 C.F.R. § 106.41(c)(7) (2018) (identifying locker rooms, practice facilities, and competitive facilities as factors relevant to determining whether equal athletic opportunity exists); see also Nondiscrimination on the Basis of Sex in Education Programs or Activities Receiving Federal Financial Assistance, 44 Fed. Reg. 71,413, 71,415–17 (Dec. 11, 1979), supra note 3 (explaining that institutions must assess the relative availability, quality, and kind of athletic benefits and opportunities and that substantial and unjustified disparities may establish noncompliance); Landow v. Sch. Bd. of Brevard County, 132 F. Supp. 2d 958, 962–66 (M.D. Fla. 2000) (evaluating disparities between baseball and softball facilities by examining their characteristics and cumulative effect).

[22] See Lauren Bradford, Franklin & Marshall Baseball Finds New Home at Penn Medicine Park, FOX43 (Aug. 12, 2026), https://www.fox43.com/article/sports/local-sports/franklin-marshall-baseball-finds-new-home-penn-medicine-park/521- (reporting that F&M planned to retain Caplan Field for practices and games as needed after team’s move to Penn Medicine Park); see also Kyle Morgan, F&M Baseball to Begin Playing at Lancaster Stormers’ Penn Medicine Park in 2027, ABC27 (Aug. 11, 2026), https://www.aol.com/articles/f-m-baseball-begin-playing-145346000.html (reporting that F&M intended to continue using Caplan Field for practices and games as needed while continuing to host camps and clinics).

[23] See Bradford, supra note 20 (reporting that F&M baseball will continue to maintain and use Caplan Field for practices and games as needed while moving its primary home to Penn Medicine Park); see also Caplan Field, supra note 20 (identifying Baker Campus Field as home of F&M softball).

[24] See NCAA, NCAA Baseball Playing Rules, Rule 1 (2026), https://www.ncaa.org/championships/playing-rules/baseball-playing-rules/ (providing governing rules and field-layout specifications for NCAA baseball); see also NCAA Softball Playing Rules, NCAA (2026–27), https://www.ncaa.org/championships/playing-rules/softball-playing-rules/ (setting forth softball field-layout specifications, including sixty-foot basepath and sport-specific playing-area dimensions).

[25] See Home of Diplomats Baseball Press Release, supra note 2 (announcing partnership’s professional-stadium access and amenities for baseball); see also Baker Campus Fields, supra note 16 (describing Caplan Field’s improvements and identifying Baker Campus Field as home of F&M softball); 34 C.F.R. § 106.41(c)(7) (2018) (identifying practice and competitive facilities as factors in determining whether equal athletic opportunity is provided).

[26] See Home of Diplomats Baseball Press Release, supra note 2 (describing partnership, its benefits for baseball, and planned use of Penn Medicine Park without identifying any corresponding softball-facility initiative); see also Baker Campus Fields, supra note 16 (identifying Baker Campus Field as softball team’s home facility and describing its existing amenities).

[27] See O’Brien, Franklin & Marshall College and Lancaster Stormers Announce Historic 8-Year Partnership Naming Penn Medicine Park the Home of Diplomats Baseball, Franklin & Marshall Coll. (Aug. 10, 2026), https://www.fandm.edu/stories/lancaster-stormers-penn-medicine-park-diplomats-baseball.html (describing  professional stadium facilities and amenities made available to F&M baseball through new partnership); see also 34 C.F.R. § 106.41(c)(2), (4)–(8) (2018) (identifying equipment, coaching, practice and competitive facilities, and medical and training services as factors relevant to evaluating equal athletic opportunity).

[28] See O’Brien, supra note 25 (describing eight-year partnership, access to professional stadium amenities, dedicated locker rooms, equipment storage, and training environments, and opportunities for collaboration between F&M Athletics and Lancaster Stormers); see also Kyle Morgan, F&M Baseball to Begin Playing at Lancaster Stormers’ Penn Medicine Park in 2027, ABC27 (Aug. 11, 2026), https://www.aol.com/articles/f-m-baseball-begin-playing-145346000.html (reporting that F&M’s athletic director identified potential benefits for student-athletes and that Stormers’ chief executive viewed arrangement as potentially beneficial for recruitment).

[29] See About the AUSL, Athletes Unlimited Softball League, https://theausl.com/about/ (last visited Oct. 11, 2026) (describing Athletes Unlimited Softball League as professional women’s softball league that launched in June 2025 to provide professional competition opportunities for world’s best softball players); see also Major League Baseball Announces Partnership with Athletes Unlimited Softball League, MLB (May 29, 2025), https://www.mlb.com/news/mlb-partnering-with-athletes-unlimited-softball-league (announcing MLB’s strategic investment in league and explaining that partnership would expand league and athlete visibility through promotional support and broadcasts).

[30] See 34 C.F.R. § 106.41(c)(2)–(10) (2018) (requiring consideration of multiple factors in evaluating equal athletic opportunity, including equipment, coaching, facilities, medical and training services, publicity, and other benefits); see also Nondiscrimination on the Basis of Sex in Education Programs or Activities Receiving Federal Financial Assistance, 44 Fed. Reg. 71,413, 71,415–17 (Dec. 11, 1979), supra note 3 (explaining that institutions must provide equivalent benefits, opportunities, and treatment to male and female athletes, but need not provide identical benefits where differences do not affect overall equivalence).

[31] See O’Brien, supra note 25 (announcing eight-year agreement establishing Penn Medicine Park as F&M baseball’s official home stadium and providing team with dedicated locker rooms, equipment storage, and access to the stadium’s training environments).

[32] See 34 C.F.R. § 106.41(c)(2)–(10) (identifying factors relevant to evaluating equal athletic opportunity, including equipment, coaching, facilities, medical and training services, publicity, and other benefits); see also Nondiscrimination on the Basis of Sex in Education Programs or Activities Receiving Federal Financial Assistance, 44 Fed. Reg. 71,413, 71,415–17 (Dec. 11, 1979), supra note 3 (explaining that equal athletic opportunity is assessed by considering benefits, opportunities, and treatment afforded to male and female athletes).

[33] See 34 C.F.R. § 106.41(c) (requiring consideration of whether institution provides equal athletic opportunity to male and female athletes); see also O’Brien supra note 25 (describing new baseball partnership and facilities and training resources it provides).