Skip to main content

The NFL Trade Physical: How Mandatory Player Medical Examinations Present an Easy Exit for NFL Teams with Second Thoughts

By: Danny LaManna*                                                                   Posted: 10/15/2026

 

In March of 2026, the Baltimore Ravens entered a trade to receive Las Vegas Raiders defensive end Maxx Crosby, hoping to add a “marquee difference-maker to their defense”.[1]  However, the Ravens ruled that Crosby failed his medical examination with the team, thereby voiding the trade agreement with the Raiders, and sending him back to Las Vegas.[2]  This complication occurred because the trade was made conditional to Crosby passing a physical examination conducted by the Ravens.[3]  Clauses of this nature, Medical Examination Conditions, are exceedingly common in sports leagues throughout the United States and the world.[4]  While Medical Examination Conditions are often treated as a formality, they remain a viable option for teams looking to protect themselves when signing new players.[5]  However, they also implicitly provide a last minute escape opportunity to a team who has second thoughts about a player after signing a trade agreement.[6]  This conflict begs the question: does the NFL expressly permit and regulate these types of conditions like other leagues, and if not, should they?[7]

 

The NFL’s Stance on Medical Examination Conditions

Despite how pervasive these clauses are in player trade deals between teams, neither the NFL Constitution and Bylaws nor the NFL Collective Bargaining Agreement (CBA) explicitly permit Medical Examination Conditions in trade agreements.[8]  The existence of these clauses is merely referenced in the Constitution and Bylaws through the process of reacquisition by the original team of a player who failed the medical exam required for their trade to be finalized.[9]  To govern player trade agreements, the NFL established a sweeping policy of commissioner oversight, dictating that all trades must be approved by the commissioner to be valid.[10]  Rather than list each clause that is permitted in these agreements in the Constitution and Bylaws or the CBA, this approach allows the commissioner to review each contract on a case-by-case basis.[11]  Unfortunately, as this frees the commissioner to rule as he sees fit, it also provides no concrete procedural or evidentiary standards for an examining team to meet, thereby widening the door to arbitrary rejections of otherwise medically healthy players.[12]

Despite the NFL CBA’s substantive silence on the inclusion of these conditional clauses in trade agreements, it does prohibit them in rookie employment contracts.[13]  Article 7 of the CBA permits a rookie contract to require a player to “undergo any physical examination requested in good faith by the Club Physician,” but the formation and binding effect of the contract cannot be made conditional on the passing of such an examination.[14]  The ambiguity created by this mixed approach may best be clarified by looking to a similarly structured policy provided by FIFA, and how that policy has been interpreted to apply to transfer agreements.[15]

 

Clarification by FIFA and CAS

This dilemma is not exclusive to the United States.[16]  International soccer star, Folarin Balogun, recently had a transfer deal collapse following a failed medical.[17]  The rules and regulations for the operation of all international club soccer leagues is provided directly by FIFA as opposed to being the product of a negotiation between the league at hand and the players.[18]  Article 18 of FIFA’s Regulations on the Status and Transfer of Players (RSTP) states that “the validity of a contract may not be made subject to a successful medical examination.”[19]  This clause is meant to be a clear prohibition on the use of a Medical Examination Conditions, and through subsequent arbitration it has been established that players will be brought in for a medical examination before any contract is signed.[20]  However, the defining feature of this clause is that the section of the governing document in which it is found only handles employment contracts between players and clubs, not transfer agreements between clubs.[21]  The Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) had the opportunity to interpret the intricacies of this clause in 2013.[22]  CAS is a dispute resolution body which FIFA has given the authority to oversee the arbitration of disputes surrounding FIFA’s rules and procedures.[23]  In an arbitration between Villarreal, a Spanish football club, and Lazio, an Italian football club, CAS ruled that a clause conditioning a loan agreement on the passing of a medical examination was permitted under FIFA regulations.[24] CAS reasoned that the common practice of holding a medical examination before the signing of the employment contract is irrelevant for purposes of the validity of [the loan agreement]”.[25]  The controlling factor in the decision was the location of the clause in the RSTP, and that the prohibition could not be assumed to extend beyond the limits of the “special provision” in which it was found.[26]  If this same reasoning were applied to the NFL’s policy on rookie contracts, it is likely a court would find no reason to extend the medical examination prohibition to trade agreements.[27]  However, the leeway granted to the examining team would remain, and with it, the risk of unfair play.[28]

 

The High Standard of the NBA

If the NFL wants to avoid relying on a similarly interpretive process, it could turn to the NBA.[29]  The NBA CBA plainly states that teams involved in a trade may make such a trade conditional on the passage of a physical examination conducted by a physician designated by the assignee-team in accordance with NBA procedures.[30]  The “NBA procedures” mentioned in this clause refer to the guidelines presented for player medical examinations in all contexts.[31] These guidelines state that the signing team is given sole discretion in determining whether the player has passed the exam, provided that this discretion is exercised in good faith and in consultation with the physician of their choosing.[32]  As long as these requirements are met, the signing team may impose any medical standard based on the player’s current ability to play the sport or the risk of a future injury, illness, or other medical condition to determine whether the player passes the exam.[33] 

 

The NFL Moving Forward

The NFL does not have a straightforward policy like the NBA, nor do they have a system in place like FIFA to help interpret their current policy.[34]  As of now, the standing of these clauses in the NFL lies at the mercy of tradition, common practice, and the whims of the commissioner.[35]  Should this lack of procedural specificity be publicly exploited, the NFL may wish they had a cut and dry approach similar to that of the NBA to rely on.[36]  Only time will tell if a Medical Examination Condition is formally challenged before the NFL has a chance to correct this gap in the next CBA.[37]

*Staff Writer, Jeffrey Moorad Sports Law Journal, J.D. Candidate, May 2028, Villanova University Charles Widger School of Law

 

[1] See Ryan Mink, Reports: Ravens Make Blockbuster Trade for Maxx Crosby, Balt. Ravens (Mar. 4, 2026, at 22:04 ET), https://www.baltimoreravens.com/news/ravens-maxx-crosby-trade-blockbuster-2026 (detailing extent Maxx Crosby was believed to improve Ravens’ defensive roster).

[2] See id. (explaining lack of detail Ravens provided Crosby or Raiders in their decision to fail his physical and terminate trade).

[3] See id. (stating existence of this clause and how natural it was in context of NFL trades).

[4] See Boaz Sity, Can Player Contracts be Made Conditional on Passing a Medical Examination? Comparing the Approaches in Football and Basketball, LawInSport (Jan. 21, 2020), https://www.lawinsport.com/topics/item/can-player-contracts-be-made-conditional-on-passing-a-medical-examination-comparing-the-approaches-in-football-and-basketball (examining extent of use of medical examination conditions in contracts within NBA and global Soccer, as well as league’s governance).

[5] See Udo Secklemenn, Contractual Hazard: Medical Examinations, Lex Sportiva (June 24, 2019), https://lexsportiva.blog/2019/06/24/contractual-hazard/ (explaining practical use of these clauses and how teams attempt to implement effect of these conditions when prohibited by league).

[6] See Curtis Crabtree, Moffit Says Browns Failed His Physical After Refusing to Take a Pay Cut, Pro Football Talk (Nov. 13, 2026, at 19:10 ET), https://www.nbcsports.com/nfl/profootballtalk/rumor-mill/news/moffitt-says-browns-failed-his-physical-after-refusing-to-take-pay-cut (explaining how John Moffit informally challenged determination that he failed his physical and questioned team’s motives of his failure).

[7] See Sity, supra note 4 (examining FIFA and NBA’s governance over medical examination clauses in trade or transfer agreements).

[8] See Collective Bargaining Agreement, Nat’l Football League & Nat’l Football League Player’s Ass’n (Mar. 15, 2020), https://nflpaweb.blob.core.windows.net/website/PDFs/CBA/March-15-2020-NFL-NFLPA-Collective-Bargaining-Agreement-Final-Executed-Copy.pdf. (demonstrating lack of attention these clauses were given in negotiations between players and teams); see also Constitution and Bylaws, Nat’l Football League (Sep. 14, 2026), https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/23170921-nfl-constitution-and-bylaws/ (demonstrating clear lack of affirmative policy towards these clauses).

[9] See Constitution and Bylaws, supra note 8, art. XVII, § 17.4(C)(3) (explaining conditions upon which traded player can be reacquired by original team that traded them).

[10] See id., art. XVI, § 16.8(A) (stating that these trades must be submitted to commissioner for approval, and following said approval, commissioner then declares trade agreement to be binding).

[11] See id. (explaining how language of each trade must be submitted to commissioner’s office, and only when it is approved is it binding on league).

[12] See id. (allowing each trade agreement to be considered with no clear reliance on prior rulings or written policy).

[13] See Collective Bargaining Agreement, supra note 8, art. VII, § 3(C)(ii) (dictating all language that Rookie contracts are prohibited from including).

[14] Compare Collective Bargaining Agreement, supra note 8, art. VII, § 3(C)(ii)(E), with Collective Bargaining Agreement, supra note 8, art. VII, § 3(iii)(C) (explaining permittance of physical examination requirements only once player’s employment has begun).

[15] See Regulation on the Status and Transfer of Players, art. 18(4), Fédération Internationale de Football Ass’n (2025), https://www.icsspe.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/06/FIFA-Regulations-on-the-Status-and-Transfer-of-Players_0.pdf (presenting similar policy including restrictions on player agreements while remaining silent on the inclusion of these clauses in interactions between teams)

[16] See Andy Hunter, Balogun Pulled out of Everton Move over Handling of his Medical, Claim Monaco, The Guardian (Sep. 2, 2026, at 13:46 ET), https://www.theguardian.com/football/2026/sep/02/folarin-balogun-transfer-deadline-day-collapse-monaco-everton-lamine-camara-chelsea (acknowledging opportunity for trade disruptions at medical examination stage in international club soccer).

[17] See id. (explaining how Balogun was not officially deemed to have failed his physical, but examination was required and difficulties arising from examination directly resulted in collapse of agreement).

[18] See Janina Rios & Angelica Medina, How World Soccer is Governed: FIFA, UEFA, and the Balance of Power, Reuters (July 29, 2026, at 15:59 ET), https://www.reuters.com/sports/soccer/how-world-soccer-is-governed-fifa-uefa-balance-power-2026-07-29/ (explaining how FIFA maintains control over rules and regulations of international club soccer).

[19] See Regulation on the Status and Transfer of Players, supra note 15 (governing language permitted in employment contracts between players and clubs).

[20] See Villarreal CF SAD v. SS Lazio Roma S.p.A, Ct. of Arb. for Sport (Mar. 7, 2014), https://jurisprudence.tas-cas.org/pdf/3314.pdf (noting that holding medical examination after signing transfer agreement was outside normal business practices for deal of this nature).

[21] See Secklemenn, supra note 5 (explaining importance of placement of medical examination conditional clause, and timing of the examination in relation to the signing of agreement).

[22] See Villarreal CF SAD v. SS Lazio Roma S.p.A, supra note 20 (ruling on inclusion of medical examination condition within transfer agreement between Lazio and Villarreal).

[23] See FIFA, Court of Arbitration for Sport, FIFA https://inside.fifa.com/legal/court-of-arbitration-for-sport (last visited Sep. 25, 2026) (explaining that rulings of CAS are binding interpretations of FIFA regulations).

[24] See Villarreal CF SAD v. SS Lazio Roma S.p.A, supra note 20, at 1 (explaining cause of dispute and final holding of case).

[25] See id. at 11 (holding that common practices surrounding timing of medical examinations are not sufficient to overrule lack of explicit prohibition on this form of clause in loan agreements).

[26] See id. at 8 (holding medical examination clause should be narrowly interpreted in scope because article in which it is found is qualified as “special provision”).

[27] See Collective Bargaining Agreement, supra note 8, art. VII, § 3(C)(ii)(E) (providing prohibition on medical examination conditions only within employment based section of regulations).

[28] See Villarreal CF SAD v. SS Lazio Roma S.p.A, supra note 20, at 12 (demonstrating that regulations of such medical examinations cannot be implied from lack of prohibition, they must be explicitly stated).

[29] See 2023 NBA-NBPA Collective Bargaining Agreement (July 2023), https://imgix.cosmicjs.com/25da5eb0-15eb-11ee-b5b3-fbd321202bdf-Final-2023-NBA-Collective-Bargaining-Agreement-6-28-23.pdf (providing explicit permission for clauses of this nature to be included in trade agreements).

[30]See id., art. 7, § 8(e)(3) (providing clear parameters for team-to-team interactions through inclusion of “trade rules” section in CBA).

[31] See id., art. 2, §13(h)(i) (stating limited requirements that team’s and their physicians must follow during the examination and determination of whether player passes).

[32] See id. (stating that examining team must act in good faith in their determinations, while failing to define how league measures this good faith).

[33] See id. (providing examples of how team may determine whether player has passed physical examination but not limiting team to exact parameters).

[34] Compare Collective Bargaining Agreement, supra note 8, art. VII, § 3(C)(ii) with 2023 NBA-NBPA Collective Bargaining Agreement, art. 7, § 8(e)(3), with Villarreal CF SAD v. SS Lazio Roma S.p.A., supra note 20 (emphasizing lack of guidance provided by NFL governing documents and supporting information relative to NBA and world soccer).

[35] See id. (stating unilateral weight of commissioner’s final word over trade terms).

[36] See Collective Bargaining Agreement, supra note 8, art. VII, § 3(C)(ii) (demonstrating how league such as NFL could easily protect against bad actors taking advantage of an ambiguous system).

[37] See How Long Does the Current CBA Go?, NFLPA, https://nflpa.com/faq/how-long-does-the-current-cba-go (last visited Sep. 16, 2026) (noting how current NFL CBA will expire in March of 2031 and negotiations for next CBA will begin).